Electric Breast Pumps Vs. Manual Breast Pumps

Technological advancement has made man marvel at how science can assist us in our most crucial times. One such awe inspiring innovation is the Breast Pump. Mothers who need to go for work even when their child needs be breast fed find breast pump to be immensely helpful. In certain medical conditions where the baby refuses to feed from the breasts, such pumps are used to collect the mother’s milk. There are 2 kinds of breast pumps - Electric and Manual. This article will do a comparison of Electric Breast Pumps Vs. Manual Breast Pumps.

Breast pumps can be categorized in to:

  • Electric Breast Pumps
  • Manual Breast Pumps

The selection between a manual pump and an electric breast pump is a tough one for those who have never used one before. While both the pumps can be used to express milk effectively, each has its merits and demerits.

What is an Electric Breast Pump?



An electric breast pump can be used to express breast milk when you are not able to feed your baby due to some reasons. This pump consists of a tiny electric motor which helps to build the rhythmic suction. As they are automatic and a mom doesn’t have to use her hands to pump, they do not leave you tired after use. Moreover as they generate the suction, active mothers can do additional things, at the same time, like reading, while using them.

Single and double electric breast pumps fall in the category of electric breast pumps. A double pump helps in expressing milk from both breasts simultaneously and hence most of the working women choose this to express more milk in a shorter time.

Due to the electric motor, electric breast pumps have the tendency to be a bit noisy, which may detract few moms as they feel that the noise will wake up their infant if they use it in the same room. On the other hand some mothers also face slight soreness since the electric pump suction can feel bit harsh while getting get used to. Nevertheless, after a few uses, the electric breast pump becomes a fast and simple way to express milk speedily.

Some of the best electric breast pumps are:

Why and when to use an electric breast pump?

Electric breast pumps express your milk rapidly. Simplicity and productivity are the two primary reasons why moms pick an electric pump.

In case that you need to express breast milk regularly, perhaps on the grounds that you are going back to work, or you have twins or you have some medical condition, you may incline toward an electric breast pump. As electric breast pumps have become more advanced, they have now more features such as:

  • double-pumping capacity, permitting you to pump both breasts simultaneously
  • tailored suction to impersonate your child's sucking
  • tailored suction to impersonate your child's sucking
  • adjustable suction levels

Electric breast pumps due to their elaborate set up are heavier than the manual breast pumps. Though with the recent technological innovations, modern electric breast pumps are lighter and quieter than ever.

Battery operated models is very convenient for busy moms. Most of these pumps also come with their own backpack which makes them more portable and also has a storage facility to keep your milk expressed.

Electric breast pumps are faster and pump more milk. They are very helpful in emptying the breast of milk.

The other benefits of an electric breast pumps are that once you switch on the pump, the suction starts in phased manner to mimic a baby’s suction. A mom can also regulate the speed and vacuum as per need. Electric breast don’t tire out your hands as they are not involved.

Electric breast pumps are a must have if you need to pump frequently throughout the day without compromising on the milk volume or taxing your hands. The only minor drawbacks are that these pumps can be bit noisy and are heavier to carry.

Advantages of Electric breast pump are

  • Electric breast pumps are more efficient. They pump more milk
  • No manual work required
  • More comfortable once you get used to it
  • Mimic baby's suction more accurately
  • Best for regular use
  • Double electric pumps save more time.
  • Ideal for busy moms

Disadvantages of Electric breast pump are

  • Electric breast pumps are heavier
  • Electric pumps have more parts
  • Electric pumps are more complex to use and wash
  • Noisier
  • Costlier than manual pumps

What is a Manual Breast Pump?

Avent Manual Breast Pump

A manual breast pump has to be pumped manually with hands to create suction and express milk. It is lot less expensive when compared to the electric breast pumps, which is the reason that some moms go for it. A manual breast pump has less parts and complexity. While learning to assemble and operate the manual pump is easy, manually creating the requisite suction is very tiring for mom. Manual breast pump is only recommended when you have to express milk only during emergencies.

Manual breast pumps work by imitating the sucking activity of a breastfeeding infant. A cup, or breast shield, is put over your nipple and air is hand pumped into making a vacuum over your breast, which establishes milk stream.

Breast milk is gathered in the bottles attached to the pump. This can be saved and fed to your infant whenever required – awesome on the off chance that you are going back to work, or are far from your infant.

Why and when to use manual breast pumps?

​In the event that you might be pumping rarely then a manual breast pump ought to have the capacity to address your issues. Since manual pumps are so little and lightweight you can advantageously pack one in a diaper bag and carry it wherever you go.

Since manual pumps are controlled by your hands, you can regulate the suction and flow of milk. For this reason, some mothers may find manual breast pumps gentler than the electric ones.

Manual breast pumps are also ideal as a stepping stone to electric breast pumps. If you have decided to use breast pumps regularly, buying a manual breast pump and getting familiar with breast pumping is recommended. Once you’re confident, you can go ahead and buy any one of our recommended breast pumps.

Advantages of Manual breast pump are

  • Manual pumps are cheap
  • Manual pumps are lightweight
  • Easy to wash
  • Easy to assemble 

Disadvantages of Manual breast pump are

  • Less efficient 
  • Less milk is extracted
  • Tiresome operation
  • Not suitable for frequent use


Electric breast pumps scores over manual breast pumps in comfort, efficiency and utility. For frequent use, electric breast pumps are the default choice

If you intend to use breast pump sparingly then manual breast pump should be used.​

Author: Marissa Claire

Hi, I am Marissa. I am a wife of a very supportive husband and mother 3 precious kids. Even though my life is not picture perfect, I have too many blessings to be counted. I am an ordinary mom who has been through some tough times.

I have tried to collate the best information available and write personal & real reviews for the benefits of parents who are confused with the plethora of breast pumps available. I have made an effort to steer clear of technical jargons and used layman language which is understood by people like us.

Electric Breast Pumps Vs. Manual Breast Pumps
Article Name
Electric Breast Pumps Vs. Manual Breast Pumps
Electric Breast Pumps Vs. Manual Breast Pumps. What are the differences between a manual breast pump and an electric breast pump
Publisher Name


Categorised in:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge